You appear to be using an outdated or unsupported web browser.
In order to experience the full and proper functionality of Ariama and many other popular websites, please update your browser to Firefox 3, Chrome 5, or Safari 5.
Ariama.com is your source for Classical music MP3s, lossless downloads, and CDs. Ariama makes it simple to find recordings and performances from your favorite classical artists and composers.

Le Grand Spectacle: Ligeti at the New York Philharmonic




Le Grand Macabre tightly weaves together everything from the lush harmonies of Wagner and Strauss to the dissonant, floating lines that recall his earliest influence, Bela Bartok, to a post-modern panoply of noises ranging from tuned car horns to the beeps of 1980s-era video games.

Introducing Gyorgy Ligeti's opera Le Grand Macabre to New York was meant to be the jewel in the crown of the first season programmed by Alan Gilbert, who became the Philharmonic's new artistic director this past September. When his appointment was  announced by the orchestra, it was immediately clear that the conductor would continue to champion new music and contemporary composers, an intention signaled by his appointment of Magnus Lindberg as composer-in-residence and the establishment of a successful new-music series called "Contact!" Ligeti, who was born to a Hungarian Jewish family in Transylvania, Romania and later became an Austrian citizen, was no stranger to the far-out; it's no accident that it was his music that was incorporated not just most famously in Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey, but also in The Shining and Eyes Wide Shut. Le Grand Macabre is a mad, feverish phantasm of an opera. It's an absurdist work long on satire and ribald humor; its score tightly weaves together everything from the lush harmonies of Wagner and Strauss to the dissonant, floating lines that recall his earliest influence, Bela Bartok, to a post-modern panoply of noises ranging from tuned car horns to the beeps of 1980s-era video games.

   The White and Black Ministers in
Le Grande Macabre
Le Grande Macabre
At the center of the opera is a character called Nekrotzar, played here by the magnificent bass-baritone Eric Owens (a world away from his unforgettable characterization of General Leslie Groves in John Adams' Doctor Atomic). Nekrotzar arrives in the dissolute country of Breughelland to announce that at midnight, he will destroy the world. (Whether or not he actually succeeds is a different--and debatable--matter altogether.) Owens' brilliance as a singer and as a theatrical performer was well-matched by a stellar cast that included the keen tenor Mark Schowalter as Piet the Pot; the lovely duo of soprano Jennifer Black and mezzo Renee Tatum as the lovers Amanda and Amando; and bass Wilbur Pauley, playing the astrologer Astradamors (and a rather unsettling doppelganger for comedian Will Ferrell). Soprano Barbara Hannigan, playing Gepopo, the chief of the secret police, dispatched her terrifyingly difficult runs with ease and panache, while countertenor Anthony Roth Costanzo, tenor Peter Tantsits, and bass Joshua Bloom made the most physical comedy out of their respective roles as Prince Go-Go, the White Minister, and the Black Minister.

This opera has easily become one of the most popular new operas of the past sixty years in Europe–why has the US shied away from it?
Ligeti and Michael Meschke co-wrote the original libretto in German, with the intention that the text be translated into the primary language of the audience at hand (so, therefore, the premiere was given in Swedish). Here, the racy libretto was sung in English, without supertitles; unfortunately, much of the meaning flew by incomprehensibly, given the density of the score and Avery Fisher's still poor acoustics. However, the outre costumes by Catherine Zuber and the other, richly layered visual elements of puppetry and video projection, designed and directed by Doug Fitch, made the meaning clear enough in an endearing mix of comedy, darkness, and a strange but vivid beauty.

What has taken so long for the US to come to this work? First premiered in Stockholm in 1978 (with substantial revisions made in 1996 before its premiere at the Salzburg Festival), the only previous staged American performances were at the San Francisco Opera in 2004. As Gilbert himself has pointed out, this opera has easily become one of the most popular new operas of the past sixty years in Europe--why has the US shied away from it?

Of course, one of the biggest questions surrounding this performance was whether or not a modern opera could attract a New York audience, given the New York Philharmonic subscribers' general and well-documented conservatism. (Indeed, the orchestra acknowledged that subscription sales accounted for only about a third of their recipts for the three performances.) Ultimately, however, Le Grand Macabre attracted sell-out crowds for all three nights, bringing to Avery Fisher Hall an audience that easily ranged from a great number of hipsters in their late teens and early twenties up through a more seasoned crowd. It was nothing short of a coup for Gilbert, and the thunderous applause that greeted him at the opera's conclusion confirmed that New York is, at last, ready for him.

Photos by Chris Lee

Browse more editorial features here
by Anastasia Tsioulcas